Please include what you were doing when this page came up and the Cloudflare Ray ID found at the bottom of this page. Costas went to. Brutal. Bernadette arrived home at around 10pm. So no they dont want thier names exposed. Sadly, I imagine that was short lived amongst the kids and as Mrs. Palmer says, things havent changed all that much. (Name will only be used to verify billing.). Now that she had her foot in the door, surely all she had to do now was simply put her hand out. Yet, when the FBI took over the case, they found that Protti, who was thought to have passed her initial lie detector test, was actually lying. Bernadette watched as Kirsten took all the success Bernadette believed. After the murder, the Costas family moved to Hawaii. She is very likable, has a very likable . Jenna Jul 13, 2016 at 7:16 pm. She said she would collect Kirsten from the house at 6 pm. Trois Costas ont . I dont think she set out to intentionally kill her, Palmer said. She took all the things I wanted! And thats why she killed Kirsten.. distant jealousy and anger. Feb 19, 2020 at 11:20 pm. She was more ashamed of what she did than killing Kirsten, Palmer said. Its never too late for Jeanette to say, I killed someone and I have to live with that the rest of my life. But she had told them shed been babysitting for the Weems family. I just wish Bernadette would come clean and public about it all. In addition, Kristen was a high school student from the United States who was murdered in June 1984 by Bernadette Protti, a classmate. Upon confirming that Bernadettes alibi was as thin-skinned as her constitution, the private investigator took this information to detectives. The FBI man thinks I did it. He asked who had stabbed her, but Kirsten was unable to speak. She remembers Protti crying during questioning in the courtroom, with her head on the table, repeating I couldnt let her tell! Incidentally, if you type Bernadettes name into Wikipedia, you are automatically directed to Kirsten Costas page. She stabbed to death a popular girl in her high school, Kirsten Costas, who refused to be friends with her and had made fun of her. Mar 19, 2019 at 2:42 pm. The resident drove Costas to a neighbor's house in Orinda because her parents were out for the evening. Girls I went to High School with who were Caddy and Stuck up now say hi to me, we outgrew the High School Antics. I just really have always wanted to know what getting weird meant. According to, I would like to remain anonymous. Similar to Kristen, Arthur and Berit Costas were well-off parents. Karen Severson and Laura Doyle were friends with Missy Avila since grade school, but as they grow older, Missy blossoms into a . It seems that Kirsten misconstrued Bernadettes desperation for her friendship as something sexual by referring to Bernadette as that way, so it is unsurprising that Mrs Palmer and others in Orinda came to the same conclusion. The speculation on whether or not this had anything to do with homosexuality, is asinine to say the least. 30 years ago, 15-year-old Costas waslured by a fake invitation for the Bob-O-Links service group dinner. Im not saying she didnt talk mean to some people, everyone does, no excuse for Murder. Kirsten was likeable to. "I lost for cheerleader and I didn't get the club I wanted and I didn't get (on the) yearbook (staff)," Protti told law enforcement during a taped confession, which was later played at the teens murder trial. Kirsten made a start towards her house, but seemed to then change her mind and started walking towards where Bernadette was parked. Her jealousy was the opener to the murder and all she had to do was throw that anger into that 18 inch knife and there you have ita dead 15 year old Northern California girl. Lots of teen girls are,:majority of teen girls are Snooty, but dont mean they deserve to die. She and her mother even went for a lovely late evening walk. Bernadette Protti of Orinda wept as she was escorted in handcuffs to juvenile hall Wednesday, minutes after she was convicted of second-degree murder. Part 2: https://clickamericana.com/topics/featured/the-real-death-of-a-cheerleader-1985/2 It was so awful. The defence wasnt disputing that Bernadette had killed Kirsten; they were only arguing that it wasnt her intention to do so when she had set up the meeting. Well, if shes now married with several children, she probably isnt gay and never was. Nancy didnt help her situation entirely: she had initially lied to investigators that she was at a movie at the time of the murder instead of with her boyfriend. Yes it is ridiculous making excuses for Bernadette. The film "is inspired by Randall Sullivans Rolling Stone article of the same name about the real-life murder of a popular, affluent and beautiful Northern California high school cheerleader at the hand of a classmate, as Lifetime described it. The Costas family left Orinda and moved to Hawaii. Mother Elaine was a homemaker, who read her bible with a stop watch. They are theories that people who have some screws missing post!! The FBIs profile was read out to her and she was asked whether the profile reminded her of anyone. Bernadette wanted to befriend her, and Kirstin was not interested. New name Jeannette Tomanka! Protti sat behind her in English and Palmers daughter noticed Protti was acting weird. Her car matched the description of what the Moraga man had told the police as well. She attacked and killed a person in cold blood. Her reasons for doing it are just not normal behavior. There would be no jury, only a judge. Bernadette Protti Kirsten Marina Costas (July 23, 1968 - June 23, 1984) was an American high school student who was murdered by her classmate, Bernadette Protti. Why did Bernadette have that knife in her car? Oxygen Insider is your all-access pass to never-before-seen content, free digital evidence kits, and much more! Is Bernadette Protti still in jail? Please dont say how could you or why because I don t understand this and I dont know why. She was sentenced to second degree murder as a juvenile (because she was one), not an adult. However, different forums say that they have completely changed their lives, moving into a different place with different identities. Both were members of the swim team, but Costas was reportedly much more popular than Protti, according to the Associated Press in 1984. People thought it was drugs, but I got that feeling from the trial., [Costas] had no way of knowing that Bernadette was thinking a great deal about her, stated another article in 1985 by People magazine. Maybe late or mid 20 s for some. Parents Know Their Children: Downplayed with Angela's parents. Being reminded of this only gave Bernadette more energy to carry out the plan she had just set in motion. Acalanes Hosts First District Dance Since COVID-19, College and Career Hosts Engineering Talk, Wrestling Outduels for Podium Spot at NCS. 1984 On June 23, 1984, Costas was lured with a phony invitation to a dinner for the Bob-o-Links, a sorority-like group at school. We do grow out of it some in our late teens and 20 s but still have moments, but not as bad. She got a light sentence because she was tried as a juvenile. It was a quite a while before Kirstens mother Berit could be interviewed. Bernadette had known that Kirsten was away. Curious Nov 29, 2016 at 7:54 am. Her attacker was Bernadette Protti; both girls were 15 years old when the . viewed 15 April 2017, Inquisitr.com Bernadette Protti, Kirsten Costas: Cheerleader Murder On IDs 1980s The Deadliest Decade, Plus The Obsession With Finding Bernadette Protti Bernadette lied to Kirstens mom about there being a Bob-O-Links dinner that night and also lied to Kirsten about a party taking place hence why Bernadette was dressed like shit in sweatpants and messy hair. Looking at the pictures, it is shocking to see that Kirsten Costas is the face of an innocent little girl. The rolling stone article was a complete fabrication. Our new series "With Friends Like These" I detail cases where friends turn upon friends - and become deadly. http://www.inquisitr.com/3750647/bernadette-protti-kirsten-costas-cheerleader-murder-on-ids-1980s-the-deadliest-decade-plus-the-obsession-with-finding-bernadette-protti/ On the 1st of April 1985, Bernadette Protti was found guilty of second-degree murder and was incarcerated for 9 years. . according to the Associated Press in1984. according to a 1985 Los Angeles Times article. Get all your true crime news from Oxygen. Many witnesses were called, including one of Bernadettes sisters who explained the presence of the knife as one she used to cut up vegetables in the Pinto on her lunch breaks. Bernadette was sure that once Kristen was her friend, success would follow. Theres a reason why we treat minors as such I dont mean to ignore or lessen the pain of the Costas family, but I can forgive her. [3] . Jeannette had an 18 inch knife in her car and lied that her sister left it there to cut vegetables when working on the road, which is obviously BS. viewed 15 April 2017, Murderpedia.com Bernadette Protti However, true to form, Bernadette was not satisfied. But despite how much the comments hurt, they only served to deepen Bernadettes resolve to make Kirsten like her. I sat in class with them both, and I cant figure it out, though the gay angle has been the one that always made the most sense to me. Bernadette admitted to her that she had lied about the dinner, but it was so that they could go to a party instead. Bernadette wasnt accepted into the yearbook committee even after the murder) Anyway, once she saw that knife, Bernadette thought to herselfI do have a reason to kill this girl. The knife caught Kirsten twice in the stomach, then in her hand as Kirsten raised her arm to protect her body. By the end of summer break in September 1984, Nancy had transferred to another school. Bernadettes was Brown woods bigger home. Time limit is exhausted. Although Bernadette was also well off, like most people in Orinda, she was not happy with her family. She was released from her incarceration at age 25. After being released Bernadette married and has several children. What about now, dont think shes not exposed and embarrassed. Kirsten would surely tell everyone how weird Bernadette was. Finally, that quick phone call was made to the Weems family. Bernadette saw her carefully cultivated outward persona crumbling with every passing mile as the two cars returned to Orinda city limits.